The Leader Mindset #46

Hi everyone,

As part of my business focus, I built a Succession Management Maturity Model Assessment (SM³A) to help organizations pressure-test a question most avoid: how strong is your succession planning, really? 

This short, free assessment cuts through good intentions and exposes whether your approach is truly mature, or quietly increasing risk.

Take the assessment yourself or forward it to your HR or talent team to get a more honest read on your leadership pipeline. In return, I will send you a comprehensive report specific to your organization.

Interested in learning more about the assessment, click the logo below.

Personal Reflections on What Makes Leaders Credible

Last weekend, I spent a lot of time thinking about what makes a leader credible.

I don’t mean leadership effectiveness or formal authority. I’m interested in how people see leaders and whether they believe a leader is worth following. Does their influence come from good judgment and trust, not just their position or title?

Credibility means others have confidence in your ability, judgment, and character.
When I thought about the leaders I’ve worked with, I noticed that their styles and personalities were all different. What stood out was how often the same signs of credibility showed up.

In my experience, these patterns came up again and again. Here is what I came up with.

“Genius-Level” Curiosity”
The most credible leaders I’ve known were intensely curious.

They always looked for ways to improve, noticed what was changing, and searched for new opportunities by asking the right questions. When they asked “why,” it wasn’t just to challenge others, but to understand complex situations. I once asked a leader why he asked so many questions. He told me, “I don’t need to have all the answers for my team. I need to know which questions to ask.” That really stayed with me.

Leaders like this earn followers because people learn from them and trust them to bring clarity to the business.

Build a Dream Team
Highly credible leaders regularly built strong teams and became known for it.

They were careful in their hiring, clear about what excellence meant, and made quick decisions when someone wasn’t the right fit. They didn’t let culture or standards slip just to be patient or polite.

Just as important, they gave talented people the chance to do meaningful, challenging work. Their teams handled the toughest problems. Most people want to be on a winning team, and credible leaders make that happen.

Being Smart Is an Asset
This might surprise some people, since intelligence in leaders is often seen as a liability. Many assume that being very smart means lacking empathy or emotional awareness. That hasn’t been true in my experience.

Leaders today face problems that are more unclear and complicated than ever. In these situations, intelligence helps leaders understand things faster. Some of the most credible leaders I’ve known were very smart. They could sort through complex information, look at situations from different sides, and quickly make sense of confusing data.

In the end, their credibility came from the brainpower they used to solve really challenging problems.

A Track Record Speaks for Itself
Credibility grows with repeated successes.

It’s not about one-time wins or lucky breaks, but about a steady record of delivering results in different roles and situations. Over time, this track record earns leaders something valuable: patience from others.

When people trust a leader to get things done, they are more willing to handle uncertainty, accept unpopular decisions, and deal with setbacks without losing confidence. That trust is earned through a history of results.

Lead Individuals, Not Roles
Credible leaders made a real effort to get to know people as individuals.

They knew that getting the best from people took more than setting clear expectations or job duties. It meant understanding what motivated each person, where they were strongest, where they needed to grow, and what they wanted from their career.

People were never treated as “cogs in the wheel.” These leaders knew their own success depended on their team’s success.

Vision Over Charisma
When it came to vision, the most credible leaders were often not the most charismatic ones.

Early in my career, I worked for a CEO who wasn’t charismatic at all. But he was great at explaining the company’s purpose and direction in simple terms. There were no catchy slogans or banners, just a clear explanation of where the company was going and why.

That kind of clarity made a difference. When people believe a leader has really thought about the future, they are much more willing to deal with uncertainty.

Transparency Builds Trust
People often think transparency just means sharing information, but in practice, it’s really about being predictable.

Credible leaders were clear about what they valued, how they made decisions, and what was and wasn’t acceptable. They didn’t use hidden agendas or play politics.

People might not always agree with them or might get frustrated, but they were rarely confused. That kind of clarity built credibility over time.

Capability Builder
Finally, credible leaders made employee development a top priority.

They coached, gave feedback, delegated real responsibility, and pushed people to reach their potential.

That investment lasts. People continued to follow leaders who helped them grow because of the loyalty it engendered.

What Matters Less Than I Thought
Some traits turned out to matter less than I thought.

Charisma rarely made or broke credibility, nor did working long hours. Both could help if the basics were already in place, but neither created credibility on its own. Even empathy mattered most when it was part of these other behaviors.

Conclusion
There are many leadership styles and frameworks, but that’s not what I’m sharing here. This is just what I’ve noticed after watching thousands of great leaders earn—and sometimes lose—the trust of those around them.

Credibility isn’t something you can claim for yourself. It’s something others decide.

The real question isn’t whether you think you’re credible.
It’s whether the people around you see you that way.

If you’re new to leadership or entering a new role, it’s worth asking how many of these credibility signals others already see in you.

Andy Noon, PhD

Sent the article? Subscribe for free.

Interested in learning more about our solutions? check them out.

Thanks for reading and look forward to seeing you again next week.

Andy